LONDON: France’s response to “yellow vest” protests could be a turning point for euro zone bond markets if it kicks off an era of increased public borrowing in the bloc and loads additional debt on to a market already nervous over the removal of ECB stimulus.
Increased public spending could be the way out for governments struggling to contain discontent over living standards and may face a strong challenge from populist politicians at May’s European parliament elections.
But if that pushes up government bond supply, it may also increase concern about some member states’ longer-term ability to service debt, and could hamstring the European Central Bank’s plan to lift interest rates.
Central to this is the situation in France, where people have taken to the streets in recent weeks wearing brightly coloured “gilets jaunes” or “yellow vests”, protesting against President Emmanuel Macron’s economic policies.
In response, Macron pledged tax cuts for pensioners and minimum wage increases that will cost France an additional 8-10 billion euros.
With Italy and Spain already ramping up 2019 spending plans, and even Germany reviewing its long-standing conservative fiscal stance, the debt could be on the rise again in the bloc.
“If there is more fiscal flexibility with Italy and France, then this is the start of a new era, an inflection point in terms of fiscal policy,” said Frederik Ducrozet, strategist at Pictet Wealth Management.
In France, the surprise spending increases will likely push the country’s budget deficit past the 3% limit mandated by the European Union.
Italy’s 2019 deficit, while lower than initially planned, will be higher than in recent years at 2.04%.
Already, France’s 10-year bond yield spread over benchmark Germany has doubled over the last six months to its widest level in 20 months at around 50 basis points.
More spending, more bonds
The immediate implications for European debt metrics don’t look too worrying – the European Commission forecasts the bloc’s budget deficit at 0.8% of gross domestic product in 2019, after 0.6% last year.
The extra French spending may add 0.1 percentage points to this, analysts estimate.
The bigger concern is that more spending in the bloc’s second and third-largest economies may set a precedent for the rest.
And it will entail more borrowing in countries already dogged by high debt and sluggish growth.
France’s debt-to-GDP ratio is close to its record high at just under 100%.
Italy’s debt is the highest in the region in absolute terms and the highest barring Greece as a percentage of economic output at around 133%, according to Eurostat.
To account for its extra spending, France has raised its 2019 bond issuance plans.
Gross issuance in Italy – already the biggest euro zone government debt issuer – is expected to rise by 10 billion euros this year to about 247 billion euros.
According to Barclays, new government bond issuance in the euro area this year, once the ECB’s reinvestment purchases are stripped out, will be the highest since 2014.
More governments could also resort to spending hikes to fend off populist challengers.
Spain, for instance, has implemented a 22% minimum wage increase, the largest annual rise in more than 40 years.
And in Europe’s biggest economy, Germany, whose ultra-conservative fiscal stance has been the subject of debate, the “yellow vest” French protests have drawn support from the left-wing “aufstehen” movement.
“The fiscal slippage will encourage the populist forces everywhere in Europe and encourage them in Southern Europe, in particular starting with Italy,” said Tristan Perrier, a macroeconomist at Amundi, Europe’s biggest asset manager with 1.5 trillion euros under management.
Many argue a fiscal boost is long overdue for a region racked by years of austerity and could support an economy that has lost momentum in the final months of 2018.
Analysts at Goldman Sachs estimate that the fiscal changes will boost euro zone GDP growth by up to 0.4 percentage points in 2019.
But fiscal expansion driven by populist forces is not necessarily a positive for the economy, others argue.
“Fiscal expansion, when you know it’s going to aid the productive potential of the economy, is a good thing.
“As long it’s a fiscal expansion which provides a longer-term solution, fine.
The problem is they tend not to be, and in which scenario we need to worry about the increment to debt,” said Karen Ward, chief market strategist at JP Morgan Asset Management.